Thoughts on this idea?
One method of making water safe to drink is by distillation. This both used heat which kills biological contaminants, and evaporation/condensation which separates the water from non-biological contaminants.
I have an idea to do this under a lower pressure system, so that the water evaporates at a lower temperature, this using less fuel.
I alm considering two glass demijohn (carbuoys) connected by tubing, with the means to reduce the pressure inside by means of a hand pump.
I have a few questions on this set-up:
0. Is this workable, or is there some fundamental flaw that I haven't realised?
1. Will reduced pressure affect the condensation point, thereby making this a pointless exercise?
2. Can sufficient vacuum be obtained by means of a hand pump to make this effective?
3. Will the distilled product still be safe with lower heat input?
4. Could it work on a solar basis with the primary container being in the sun and the receiver being in the shade?
Thanks for any input on this.
Water distillation under vacuum
- Jamesey1981
- Posts: 983
- Joined: Fri Sep 12, 2014 11:46 pm
- Location: A Postbox on Baker Street.
Re: Water distillation under vacuum
The problem you will have is with maintaining the vacuum, it may also affect the condensation point but I'm not sure of that, (edit: thinking about it, it probably won't condense at all if you manage to get the pressure below the vapour pressure of water at the temperature you're trying to condense it) but as the water evaporates and turns into water vapour it will expand, thus increasing the pressure in your container.
You could keep pumping and maybe you could keep it under vacuum, but even if you manage it, you're going to be removing gas from your system, which will include the water vapour that you're trying to condense.
So in summary, if you have a vacuum you won't have any vapour to condense, and if you don't have a vacuum you're wasting your effort pumping.
You could keep pumping and maybe you could keep it under vacuum, but even if you manage it, you're going to be removing gas from your system, which will include the water vapour that you're trying to condense.
So in summary, if you have a vacuum you won't have any vapour to condense, and if you don't have a vacuum you're wasting your effort pumping.
That is not dead which can eternal lie, and with strange aeons even death may die.
Re: Water distillation under vacuum
You are right; I had completely forgotten about expansion. I guess that rules out using a sealed system.Jamesey1981 wrote:but as the water evaporates and turns into water vapour it will expand, thus increasing the pressure in your container.
Re: Water distillation under vacuum
I'm no expert but wont demijohns collapse under the vacum? I've seen metal 55 gallon oil drums crushed by just lowering the pressure inside, and that wasn't even close to a vacum.
Re: Water distillation under vacuum
Hi,
Using a vacuum will not work as the water vapour will fill the vacuum.
If you can create a vacuum then a better use would be to draw the water through a filter system, in the same way you suck water through one of those water purifying straws.
Using a vacuum will not work as the water vapour will fill the vacuum.
I think the danger here is that the steam pressure will burst the demijohn as it is a sealed system, think about the power of a steam engine.sniper 55 wrote:I'm no expert but wont demijohns collapse under the vacum? I've seen metal 55 gallon oil drums crushed by just lowering the pressure inside, and that wasn't even close to a vacum.
If you can create a vacuum then a better use would be to draw the water through a filter system, in the same way you suck water through one of those water purifying straws.
"Just when one least expects it, the unexpected always happens" - Dr. Rance
Re: Water distillation under vacuum
All valuable points.
I was working on the assumption that a partial vacuum would make it easier for the water to vapourise. But I think a side effect is that it would be less likely to condense.
The system I was thinking of would use rubber bungs which would easily blow off if the steam pressure was too high.
Having looked in to this a bit more, it seems that a hand pump can achieve at the most 0.8 atm which leads to a boiling point reduction to about 94°C ... not really worth pursuing.
I was working on the assumption that a partial vacuum would make it easier for the water to vapourise. But I think a side effect is that it would be less likely to condense.
The system I was thinking of would use rubber bungs which would easily blow off if the steam pressure was too high.
Having looked in to this a bit more, it seems that a hand pump can achieve at the most 0.8 atm which leads to a boiling point reduction to about 94°C ... not really worth pursuing.
-
- Posts: 544
- Joined: Fri Oct 31, 2014 9:33 pm
- Location: Area 3
Re: Water distillation under vacuum
If you lower the boiling point significantly then you will not kill the bugs and nasties. If I recall correctly water needs to be held at a rolling boil (under normal pressure) for a length of time to ensure bugs are killed.
If guns are outlawed then only the outlaws will have guns....
-
- Posts: 3052
- Joined: Fri Feb 08, 2013 11:32 pm
Re: Water distillation under vacuum
Surrey: Not exactly, but near enough
The minimum temperature recommended to kill nasties is 70 degrees C, however this needs to be maintained for a while to be affective and is difficult to guess in the field.
Everyone can tell when water is at a Rolling boil and holding at that point for a minute or two ensures that the water has been over the magic 70C for long enough to kill anything thats likely to affect human health.
Even on the top of Everest water boils at over 70C...... Not by much though
The minimum temperature recommended to kill nasties is 70 degrees C, however this needs to be maintained for a while to be affective and is difficult to guess in the field.
Everyone can tell when water is at a Rolling boil and holding at that point for a minute or two ensures that the water has been over the magic 70C for long enough to kill anything thats likely to affect human health.
Even on the top of Everest water boils at over 70C...... Not by much though
jennyjj01 wrote:"I'm not in the least bit worried because I'm prepared: Are you?"
"All Things Strive" Gd Tak 'GarLondonpreppy wrote: At its core all prepping is, is making sure you're not down to your last sheet of loo roll when you really need a poo.