Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Kit, Clothing, Tools, etc
metatron

Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by metatron »

I was reading the "non locking knives, a rant!" and it got me thinking about good, under £15, legal knife options you can carry with out having a good reason, (although I don't like apple skins so I'd say pealing an apple is a good reason for something locking, the police may not sadly).

So I've picked three from my collection, all well under £15.

Victorinox Solo - £14
CRKT Edgie - £12
Imperial Schrade Sodbuster - £8

Image

Victorinox Solo is a solid contender, the blade steel Victorinox use is somewhat a mystery, certainly it doesn't appear to be well documented what they use, its certainly a surgical grade stainless steel and I've never had any issues with rust over the years, as well as edge retention from heavy use.

The main pluses of the Victorinox Solo, is consistent quality across their range, a choice of handle materials and its general acceptance by non-knife people who see it as a tool, not as a weapon, which you will get from some of the more "tactical" looking blades such as the first and second gen Lansky World Legal blades.

Image
(pen for idea of size)


The negatives, would be the complete lack of a pocket clip, which admittedly isn't super important with knifes this size, additionally they are quite stiff to open, so even if you buy an after market thumb stud their not easy to open one-handed and with out a thumb stud its impossible to open one-handed, which with me is a massive negative.

Overall a great knife for the money, due to its consistent quality, solid lock-up and edge retention.

CRKT Edgie is an interesting knife for the money, when you first pick one of these up the weight is noticeable for such a small knife and the only thing that lets it down when you first handle it, is the choice of handle material which is a textured plastic. The blade material is a 420J2 Stainless Steel, which really isn't a great blade steel as its a little on the soft side. This is overcome by having an integrated sharpener within the handle, which through use has proven to keep the knife razor sharp.

Image

Image

The pros, besides the low-cost would be the inclusion of the pocket clip and large-ish thumb hole, which allows for one-handed opening. Additionally the chisel ground element on the blade which I thought I'd dislike and sharpener combination actually comes in really useful for basic food prep tasks when out and about.

The negatives, basically come down to the choice of materials, primarily the low-cost blade steel they went with and handle materials. The pocket clip although useful and with great pocket retention, is not deep carry and the top of the knife is clearly visible which I'm not fond of.

Image

Overall for the money it's well worth consideration, and as an EDC blade the legal nature and one-handed opening makes this one of my go to knifes.

Imperial Schrade Sodbuster is a fantastic knife for the money, and is very similar to the Victorinox Solo, both in size, blade thickness and build quality. The choice of materials does make this feel and look like a much more expensive knife, and the use of 400 Stainless Steel for the blade is more than sufficient for the type of everyday tasks you would be using a small pocket knife for. The edge retention and rust resistant properties keeps this little blade going for a considerable amount of time before it needs to be re-sharpened.

Image

The pros, besides the overall appearance and build quality would be the stiffness of lock-up and it comes razor sharp from the manufacturer. It also has a very non-aggressive look which makes it a nice option if you plan on having it out and using it a lot, and don't want to worry people.

The negatives, although the knife was sharp from the manufacturer, I found that the quality of the grind when I've ordered several of them as gifts has not been consistent, with the occasional removal of a little too much material on the blades tip. It also lacks a pocket clip and cannot be opened one-handed without the purchase of a aftermarket thumb stud.

Overall for the money it's worth having one or two of these and the feel of this low-cost option surpasses a lot of the more expensive knives.

Conclusion

If I could only have one I probably go with the CRKT Edgie, for no other reason that the knife can be opened and closed one-handed. The blade material and handle are not an ideal choice but with the inclusion of the integrated sharpener, the downside to the blade material is less of a problem. Even if you're going with an alternative EDC blade, I'd give the CRKT Edgie an honourable mention as a food prep knife when camping.

Other notable cheap legal EDC options such as the non locking Opinel are good, although I found handle finishes to be all over the place and the first and second gen Lansky World Legal, which I didn't like the look of and had some odd comments from people who saw them more as a weapon, then as a tool due to their blade shape.
uivenger
Posts: 9
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2015 8:44 pm
Location: Staffordshire / South Wales

Re: Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by uivenger »

Metatron, where did you source the Edgie? :?:
Area 9 (Home Weekends)
Area 12 (Work Mon-Fri)
metatron

Re: Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by metatron »

uivenger wrote:Metatron, where did you source the Edgie? :?:
Their still on sale through Heinnie for £11.95
http://www.heinnie.com/crkt-edgie-self- ... -now-12-95
User avatar
Deeps
Posts: 5797
Joined: Sun Nov 09, 2014 8:36 pm

Re: Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by Deeps »

A good read, cheers. I like to carry a SAK Spartan, the extra 'bits and bobs' have come in handy over the years, I've used them all at different times, even the reamer thingy . Not much bigger than the blade only ones. I've got a Camper too but the wee woodsaw seems to make it just that bit 'bigger' and I'm not so keen on it for EDC, probably me just being a bit nuts. :lol:

You raise a good point about the appearance, as you say, most folk don't really bat an eyelid about a 'good old Swiss army knife' but might take exception to something a bit more substantial, even if it is less than 3 inches.
User avatar
munchh
Posts: 1021
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2012 12:48 am
Location: Gatwick

Re: Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by munchh »

I have a sodbuster, delivered to me for £9.90, really nice in your hand. :D

worth a look here
http://edcgear.co.uk/knives-uk-legal-carry.asp
AREA 3
I'm not antisocial, just anti idiot.
If you use the phase "man up" you have alot to learn.
"Wise men speak because they have something to say, fools, because they have to say something" Plato.
metatron

Re: Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by metatron »

Deeps wrote:A good read, cheers. I like to carry a SAK Spartan, the extra 'bits and bobs' have come in handy over the years, I've used them all at different times, even the reamer thingy . Not much bigger than the blade only ones. I've got a Camper too but the wee woodsaw seems to make it just that bit 'bigger' and I'm not so keen on it for EDC, probably me just being a bit nuts. :lol:

You raise a good point about the appearance, as you say, most folk don't really bat an eyelid about a 'good old Swiss army knife' but might take exception to something a bit more substantial, even if it is less than 3 inches.
I had both the first gen and second gen Lansky World legals, before I sold them to friends. They have really aggressive styling as I think their going for that tacticool look that sells well when its hung up in a display, I'm just not convinced the blade shapes add anything to their usefulness and is more of a hindrance, as for me a knife is there to be used and if you are thinking "do I really want to take this out of my pocket" its the wrong type of blade. As a knife, they do a fine job, and the blade thickness and construction gives them a solid feel, its just the look and comments that I found off-putting. Its the same issues I have with carrying Tanto tipped blades, sure their great for combat, but I'm not carrying one for that.
Yorkshire Andy
Posts: 9888
Joined: Thu Oct 03, 2013 4:06 pm

Re: Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by Yorkshire Andy »

If your roughing it, Your doing it wrong ;)

Lack of planning on your part doesn't make it an emergency on mine
User avatar
tanstaafl
Posts: 548
Joined: Sat Dec 29, 2012 12:34 pm
Location: Hereford

Re: Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by tanstaafl »

Another vote for the CRKT Edgie, a lot of the guys on the knife forums dont like it, but its a shove in your pocket thats always sharp knife....... :D


Dont forget the Chinese knives ,Ganzo, Enlan and Sanrenmu) , everyone who has tried them loves them and if you do some research you will find many are brand name knives without the branding , I have a £8 Sanrenmu made on the same production line as its £25 twin Boker ........and they ARE identical a work colleague has the Boker :D

Image







look here https://www.fasttech.com/category/1901/ ... r-survival



But I carry this most days... a 1954 British Army Knife ( well mine from Belgium, but built by us) and can be had a NOS for a fiver...


Image







The Opinels are good but only the smaller ones are legal EDC, the others are lockers
User avatar
Deeps
Posts: 5797
Joined: Sun Nov 09, 2014 8:36 pm

Re: Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by Deeps »

tanstaafl wrote:Another vote for the CRKT Edgie, a lot of the guys on the knife forums dont like it, but its a shove in your pocket thats always sharp knife....... :D


Dont forget the Chinese knives ,Ganzo, Enlan and Sanrenmu) , everyone who has tried them loves them and if you do some research you will find many are brand name knives without the branding , I have a £8 Sanrenmu made on the same production line as its £25 twin Boker ........and they ARE identical a work colleague has the Boker :D

Image







look here https://www.fasttech.com/category/1901/ ... r-survival



But I carry this most days... a 1954 British Army Knife ( well mine from Belgium, but built by us) and can be had a NOS for a fiver...


Image







The Opinels are good but only the smaller ones are legal EDC, the others are lockers
I know these from the Navy as a 'pussers dirk', I used to carry one too, fortuitously as it turned out. I had a summer job cutting grass for the council and part of the job was hedge cutting, anyhoo, my own fault entirely but when the blades were jammed with branches I wasn't turning it off to remove them, long story short, I got the end of my finger caught between the blades and used the marlin spike on the knife to prise the blades apart. I was up some scaffolding at the time and my workmates went whiter than I did (apparently) watching me work the blades apart. The only reason I had it was because I'd lost my SAK a couple months earlier and I was too skint to get one straight away. On the bright side, I got a paid week off to recover. :D
User avatar
Bad Wombat
Posts: 195
Joined: Wed Jan 15, 2014 10:03 pm
Location: Worcestershire, UK

Re: Cheap but good EDC knifes.

Post by Bad Wombat »

Got the Victorinox Solo in my pocket right now. Quality knife, and the least likely to cause offence when carried around town.